특수교육연구 발간 및 투고 규정 및 연구윤리규정.pdf

- 1 - 1994. 02. 26. 14 1 1998. 10. 24. 60 2 2002. 04. 03. 74 3 2005. 08. 08. 101 4 2009. 03. 12. 117 5 2009. 06. 24. 125 6 2012. 06. 14. 160 7 2012. 09. 11. 167 8 2013. 10. 04. 189 9 2017. 04. 17. 237 10 2019. 04. 23. 260 11 2019. 07. 31. 267 12 2019. 12. 11. 268 13 2020. 11. 19. 278 14 2021. 04. 19. 287 1() . 2() <> 3( ) . . <> 2 . 4( ) ( ) . 1 10 20 . , . - 2 - , . . 1 . 4 . 5( ) . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6() 3 2 . . 7() . , . 8( ) 1 . . . 1 3 . 9( ) . 1. - 3 - 2. 3. 4. 5. () 1 2 . 1. 1 , , , . 90 ~ 100 80 ~ 89 70 ~ 79 69 2. 2 , . 3 . 1. : . 2. : . . , . 3. : . . . 4. : . 2 . 1. 2 , 1 . . : , . . : , . , . . . : , . . 1 1 , . - 4 - 2. 2 , 1 . . : , . . , . . : , . , , 1 1 , . 3. 2 , 1 . . : , . . , . . . : , . 4. 2 , 1 . 3 , . . : , . , 1 1 , . . : , . . , - 5 - . . . : , . , 1 1 , . . : , . , 1 1 , . , 1 . . <1 > 1 2 3 2 3 10( ) - 6 - 7 , . . 11( ) . . 12() , . 13( ) 3(4 30, 8 31, 12 31) . 1 : 4 30(1 31 ) 2 : 8 31(5 31 ) 3 : 12 31(9 30 ) 14 <> 15( ) . 16() . 17() 10 , . , APA . . - 7 - () . ( ) . : , . , . , , . : (1) () (2) () (3) () - 9 - 2007. 12. 11. 112 1 2008. 08. 14. 114 2 2009. 06. 24. 126 3 2019. 12. 11. 269 4 2021. 04. 19. 288 1() ( ) . 2() () . 3( ) . 4( ) , . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. , 8. , 9. , , ( ) 10. 5( ) . 1. , - 10 - . 2. . 3. , 3 . . . . . 4. , . . . . 5. , , . , . 6. . 7. . 6( ) 1. , . 2. , . - 11 - 7( ) 1. . . 2. . 8( ) ( ) . 9( ) , . 10( ) 1. 4 9 . 2. . 3. . 4. 1 . 11() 1 . 12() . 13( ) . 1. 6 2. 3. 1 14( ) . - 12 - .

2021-12-07

국가연구개발 연구윤리 길잡이(개정본).pdf

31 58 22 2 ( 2022.5.19.) . : 1 1 1. 3 2. 4 3. 5 4. 7 2 9 1 11 1. 11 2. 13 3. 13 2 14 1. 14 2. 15 3 18 1. 18 2. 19 3 21 1 23 1. 23 2. 23 2 23 1. 23 2. 25 3. 29 4. 30 5. 33 CONTENTS 6. 34 7. 35 3 38 1. 38 2. 41 4 47 1 51 1. 51 2. 52 3. 55 4. 60 2 62 1. 62 2. 64 3 67 1. 67 2. 67 3. 68 70 1 70 2 70 1. 70 2. 77 3. 78 4. 79 5. 82 6. 85 7. 87 3 89 1. 89 2. 90 4 94 1. 94 2. 96 3. 100 4. 101 5. 103 5 105 1 107 1. 107 2. 109 3. 109 4. 110 5. 111 2 112 1. 112 2. 114 3. 116 4. 118 3 121 1. 121 2. 122 3. 125 4. 127 CONTENTS 6 133 1 135 1. 135 2. 136 2 136 1. 136 2. 139 3 140 1. 140 2. 141 4 142 1. 142 2. 142 5 143 1. 143 2. 145 3. 145 7 149 1 151 1. 151 2. 151 2 153 1. 153 2. 153 3. 154 4. 154 3 156 1. 156 2. 157 3. 158 4. 159 8 161 2007 , . , . 2021 () (T/F) . , . , , . T/F . , . . , . , , . T/F . . 2022 2 21 () TF 2021 5 ( ) 2022 5 19 . , , , , . , , , . 4 : , , : , , , . . . 2022 5 1 1 1 1 3 2 4 3 5 4 7 1 3 1 1. ( ) , < >1) ( 71) 58 ( 314 58) 1) , , (2021.06) ( 17343) 6( ) . () 7. 7 7( ) . 4 58 57 - 57 : ( 31287) 57( ) 312 ( ) . 2. - , , - , , * , * , (), ( ) () 3. 31( ) . ( 31287) 58( ) 314 . 1. 45 2. , 3. 4. 5. 6. 1 5 8 , 58 1 , , , , , , - (: ) 2022 5 19 (22.5) 3. 58 , 23 ( 17343) 2() . 3. . . . 2 ( ) . 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 169 . ( 31287) 2() ( ) 23 . 1. 2 2. 6 * * 15 () 31 , , - , , 58 - , * , ** * , ** 1 7 4. , , - , , , ( ), 2 2 9 1 11 1 11 2 13 3 13 2 14 1 14 2 15 3 18 1 18 2 19 2 11 2 1 1. (research integrity) , , , , , , , , 2) - , - , - , , , , ( (, 2018, p8)) - , , ( , 2019, p10) - (, , , , , ) , , , , , ( , 2021, p13) - (research integrity) 2) National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine 2017. Fostering Integrity in Research. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/21896: p38 12 < > Fostering Integrity in Research (National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, Medicine, 2017) - (objectivity): - (honesty): - (openness): - (accountability): - (fairness): , - (stewardship): The European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity (All European Academies, 2017) - (reliability): , , , - (honesty): , , , , , - (respect): , , , , - (accountability): , , , Singapore Statement on Research Integrity (2010) - (honesty) - (accountability) - (professional courtesy and fairness) - (good stewardship of research on behalf of others) < > 5() . 1. . 2. . 3. . 4( ) ( , , , ) . , . . 2 13 2. ( 45) 45 ( 581) ( 18069) 4( ) , . ( 31287) 58( ) 314 . 1. 4 5 ( 17343) 31( ) . 3. 2 , , - , , - , 2 45 , , , 3( ) 14 2 1. , () - - , - , , , , ( 17671) 4( ) , . ( 17343) 7( ) . 1. 2. , 3. 2 15 2. 3) 1) , 2) , , - - (), , () , , - , , , , , , 3) , , , , , 4) , , , , , 3) , 16 5) < >4) 1. , , 2. ( , , DNA ) , , , , 3. , , , , , (2021.3), , 4) , , , . , (2019) p26-49 2 17 < >5) , , , 1 ? 2 , , ? 3 ? 4 , , , , , , , , ? 5 (paraphrasing) (summarizing) ? 6 ? 7 2 1 ? 8 , ? 9 ? 10 , ? 11 ? 12 ? 13 ? 14 ? 15 ? 16 ? 5) , , , . , (2019) p12-13 18 3 1. * , * , , - - , , , , - , , ( 17343) 6( ) . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 7 < > 4( ) . 2 19 2. , - , , - , , , ( 263) , . ( 263) 6( ) . . , , , , , - , , , , , - - , 3 3 21 1 23 1 23 2 23 2 23 1 23 2 25 3 29 4 30 5 33 6 34 7 35 3 38 1 38 2 41 3 23 3 1 1. , , , , , , , - , , - , , , 2. - 2 1. , , . * * 31( ) 56( ) 24 ( 17343) 31( ) ( ) . 1. ( 31287) 56( ) 3111 . 1. : 2. : , 3. : 4. : - , < > * * , , 6) , 5623 3 25 < > 5() . 1. . 2. . 3. . , , , , ( 263) 6( ) , , , , . < > 5( ) , , , , . 2. , * , 7) * , , (, ), , , , , ( ) , , , , 6) , , (2015) p271 7) Committee on Publication Ethics, GUIDELINES ON GOOD PUBLICATION PRACTICE (1999) 26 , ( 263) 1214 , . . . < > 12( ) . . 1. 2. 3. 4. 10() , , , . 12( ) . 1. , , 2. 3. < > 12( ) . . 10() , , , . . 44( ) , . , . 3 27 * , , - , * COPE8) , < > / (Authorship) , . , , , , (- , Hardy-Littlewood Rule). , 2004 9). , , (1) ; (2) . ; (3) , ; , , , , , 8) Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) 9) American mathematical society, The Culture of Research and Scholarship in Mathematics: Joint Research and Its Publication (2004) 28 < > 13( ) . 10() , . 13( ) . . , , , , . , , , , , < > 10( ) , . 11() . . , * . , * , , , < >10) IRB, IACUC , , , 3 29 11) , . () . Acknowledgements should be brief, and should not include thanks to anonymous referees and editors, inessential words, or effusive comments. A person can be thanked for assistance, not excellent assistance, or for comments, not insightful comments, for example. Acknowledgements can contain grant and contribution numbers. 3. , < >12) - . , - < > 14( ) . , . 10() . , . 10) , , , . , (2019) p44 11) Formatting guide, Nature, (2021.11.25. ), https://www.nature.com/nature/for-authors/formatting-guide 12) , . , (2020) p.19 30 4. 2018 5 9 , , ( ) , * * (19 ) (, 4 ) , 13) ( 263) 5( ) , . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. , 8. , 9. , , ( ) 10. 6( ) . . . . . . , , , , . , , . 13) , , (20.04.10) 3 31 , - , - ( ) , <( ) >14) . - : . - : , . , [ 2021-102, 2022.1.1. ] - : . ( ) , . - : . (): , , - : , . - : . 14) , , (), (2020.04.10.) 32 < >15) () () () () () - A (///) - B (///) - (///) (4 ) R&E (Conference) (Journal) < > - : - : - : - : < > - : - : - : - : . : () 15) , , (), (2020.04.10) 3 33 5. , , - Nature * ** , (disclosure) * (funding), (employment), (personal financial interests) ** , , , 16) 2001 Nature , 2003 , 2018 1 , , 16) Competing interests, Nature portfolio (2021.12.13. ), https://www.nature.com/nature-portfolio/editorial-policies/competing-interests 34 6. 17) , , , - , , , , , 18) < >19) , , , . , , , < > 6( ) , . 1 ( ) . 17) , : , 157 (2006), p.1-12 18) 9 , (2019) 19) , , , . , (2019), p.16 3 35 7. , 20) , , , , , < > ()(predatory journal) (fake conference) (naive) , (cognizant) , (pseudo- scientist) . , , 20) , , , . , (2019), p.52-53 36 , - ( ) 21) (2018.09.), (2018.10.), 21) , (2018.10.01.) < ()> 3-1. () , (http://safe.koar.kr) < ()> () , ( 3-2. ) () ( 3-3. ()) () ( ) () ( ) , 3 37 , , , , , () [ 3-3] , . ( ) . , , . ( ) . . , () 3-2. () () () 3-3. () () ( ) () , * (http://safe.koar.kr) 38 < > () . , ( ) (IRS) () . , () . , * . / * (: ) 3 1. 21 ( 17343) 21( ) . ( 31287) 44( ) 211 ( ) . 1. 21 2. 212 . 1. 2. 3. 23 4 4. 1 3 3 39 - , * 46 * 212 , ( 31287) 45( ) 212 ( ) . 1. 31 2. . . . 22 . 191 46( ) 213 . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. < >22) 1. 2. 3. 4. 40 * * 22 , , , < > 16( ) . 7 ( ) . 22) , (2021.3.23. ) 5. 6. 7. 8. , , , 9. 1. 2. 3. ( ) , 4. () - 11( ) 5. 6. ( ) , 7. () 3 () 3 41 2. 17 * * ( ) - , , ( 2021-12) 17( ) , . 1. 2. , , , , , 3. , , 4. ( ) 5. 6. , 7. , 8. , 9. , (ITC) , 10. 11. () 12. 1 11 25( ) . 1. , , . , 42 , < >23) O( ) . . O( ) . , , . 1. ( , ) 2. 3. 23) , (2021.2.26.), 2. . , , . , . 2. , 3. , ( ) 3 43 < >24) , * * Q1. ? Q2. , , ? , ( R&D ) Q3. ? Q4. ? *, ** * ** , , / Q1. ? Q2. / , , ? Q3. / ? / Q4. / ? 24) , (2021.2.26.), 3. 44 [ 3-1] ()25) O/X 1 ? 2 ? SCI, KCI, SCOPUS * OA DOAJ(Directory of Open Access Journal), OASPA(Open Access Scholary Publishers Association) 3 ? 4 ? 5 ? ( ) 6 ? 7 ? , 8 ? (Guarantee) 9 ( ) ? / 10 ? http://safe.koar.kr , (http://safe.koar.kr) Think/Check/ Submit (https://thinkchecksubmit.org/) 25) , (2020.3.5.) p.6 3 45 [ 3-2] ()26) O/X/ 1 ? , 2 ? () 3 ? , url 4 ? , 5 ? , 6 , () ? 7 ? 8 ? (4 ) 9 ? , , 10 ? http://safe.koar.kr 11 ? () , 12 ? , , Think/Check/Attend(https://thinkcheckattend.org) 26) , (2020.3.5.) p.5 46 [ 3-3] ()27) : : OOOO.OO.OO ~ OOOO.OO.OO ( X) : : , XX , ( XX) / (: ) x = x = x = . : () 27) , 4 4 47 1 51 1 51 2 52 3 55 4 60 2 62 1 62 1) 62 2) 64 2 64 3 67 1 67 2 67 1) , , 67 2) 67 3) 68 3 68 1) 68 2) 69 70 1 70 2 70 1 70 2 77 3 78 4 79 5 82 6 85 7 87 3 89 1 89 2 90 4 94 1 94 2 96 3 100 4 101 5 103 4 51 4 4 , 4 [] . 1 1. (Conflict of Interest, )28) () () , () < > () , (private-capacity interest) (official duties and responsibilities) 29) (OECD 2005, p.13) 1 ( ) 2 ( ) 30) (Thompson 1993, p.573) ( 24), 22 28) , , 29) OECD 2005. Managing Conclict of Interest in the Public Sector 30) Thompson, Dennis F. 1993. Understanding Financial Conflicts of Interest. New England Journal of Medicine 329: 573-6 52 ( 18191) 2() . 4. . ( 17989) 22( ) . . , . . , () () 2. , 2013 151 151 - (81.12.31, 83.1.1.), (08.2.29., 08.2.29) ( 03.2.18, 03.5.19.), (15.3.27., 16.9.28 ), (21.5.18., 22.5.19. ) , - (3), (32), (4), (62), (144), (146) - () 4 53 ( 17989) 1() , , , , . 8 , - (5), (52), (53), (54), (55), (56), (10), (102), (11), (12), (13), (132), (133), (14), (15), (16), (17) - , ( 18438) 1() , . 8( ) 7 . 1 . 1. 2. 3. 4. - - , , 54 ( 18581) 1() () 5( ) 3 . 1. ( . ) 2. , , , , , , , <, > 8( ) 1 100 300 . 1 . - (5), (6), (9), (10), (14), (16) - (11), (12) ( 18191) 1() . 4 55 < > (21.5.18., 22.5.19.) (03.2.18, 03.5.19.) (08.2.29., 08.2.29) (15.3.27., 16.9.28) ( 03.2.18, 03.5.19.) (, 8 ) (81.12.31, 83.1.1.) 3. 314 58 56 ( 18645) 2() . 3. . . . 2 ( ) . 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 169 . ( 32528) 58( ) 314 . 3. < > ( ), , , , (1: ) - , , (2: ) , - , , , - , (3: ) 4 57 , - 4 [] - (8 - (1), (2) ) - , ( ) , - , 1 2 3 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2022 1 1,352 , 2022 1 350 8 58 < > - , - , 32 4 , < > 3() ( ) . 1. 2. , 3. 4 ( ) ( ) () 8. ( ) , () 12. 32 ( ) 32() 928 , . 1. 2. 3. ( ), 4. ( ), 5. / / . , 5 . / 4 59 . . . . , , , , , ( ) . 32 ( ) . , , , (21) , 5 . . . . 1 (23) / . . , , , , , , , ( ) . 32 . 4 . , , . 2 12 (21) . . . 1 . 1 . 1 (22) / / 60 4. - , , , - . , . . , , , , , , , ( ) . . . 32 . 4 . , (21) . . . 1 . 1 (22) / ( ) 4 61 - - - , - 5813 ( 32528) 58( ) 314 . 3. 62 2 1. 1) ( ) , , , - 2013 151 151 , < > , , , , , , , / < > (, , , ) , , () , , < > , , , (, ) , , , , , < > , , , , , , 4 63 < > 18 ( ) . 1. : 2. : , 3. : 4. : , , 5. : 1 4 39( ) . , . , . , . 43( ) , , , . ( 19 ) (, 4 ) ( ) [ 6 ] , . [ 7 ] . 2 3 . 46( ) , . , . 64 2) , 9 - , , , , , , - , < > 5, 15 6 9 10 14 16 11 12 2. - , < > / , , 5( ) 5( ) () , () , , , , , 11( ) 54( ) 15( ) 56( ) 4 65 () () , , , , ( ) / / / 6( ) () () () () ( ) 9( ) 16( ) 14( ) 12( ) 12( ) 55( ) 10( ) 10( ) 53( ) 15( ) 10( ) 53( ) 15( ) () / , , , , 16( ) 11( ) 66 , , < > , < >31) - - - () - , , , , - - - () / 4 67 3 1. , , 2. 1) , , , , - , , , . , . , . <, > 40( ) . , , . . , . 2) 31) 68 3) , , - - - , , , , 3. 1) , , < > 5( ) , () 8. , 39( ) . , . , . , . 4 69 < > 47() . . , . 13( ) , . , , . . 19( ) , . , , , 18 , . . ( 19 ) (, 4 ) ( ) [ 1 ] . [ 2 ] . , . . 2) , , 70 1 - , , , , () 32), - 2 1. 14 ( ) 33) - - , , , 32) () ( 2016. 3. 4.), ( 2022. 1. 18.), ( 2022. 3.29.) 33) () , () 71 < > Q) A B . B C . ? A) () () 14 . , , , - , , , - , - , , , , ( 18191) 5( ) ( . ) 14 ( . ) . 1. , , , , , 2. 3. , 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. , , , 14. 15. , , , , , 16. , , , 72 , 14 - -

2022-05-20

붙임 국가연구개발 연구윤리 길잡이 개정본(최종).pdf

2023-06-01

대학의 연구윤리 확립을위한 길잡이(대학용).pdf

Korean University Council of Research Ethics CHAPTER 1. 06 2. 07 CHAPTER 1. (1) 10 2. (2) 11 3. (3) 16 4. (4) 18 CHAPTER 1. (5) 22 2. (6) 24 3. (9) 29 CHAPTER 1. (11) 32 2. (12) 33 3. (13) 41 02 01 03 04 CHAPTER 1. (14, 15) 46 2. (16, 27) 51 3. (21, 22) 57 4. (17, 18, 19, 20) 63 CHAPTER 1. (26) 80 2. (29) 81 3. (31) 84 CHAPTER 1. ( 1, 2) 90 CHAPTER 95 96 06 05 07 08 01 CHAPTER 1. 2. 1. 2007 ( ) , , , , 263(2018.07.16.) STEP 01 . STEP 02 6 CHAPTER 01 2. 01 STEP 02 STEP 03 STEP 01 _ . 02 _ 2018 , , , , , , 03 _ , , , , 7 02 CHAPTER 1. (1) 2. (2) 3. (3) 4. (4) 1. (1) 1() 15 , , . ( ) ( ) ( ) , ( , , ) - . , : . ( ) . : 1 1 () ( ) , , , . : 1() ( ) ( '' ) , , . 10 CHAPTER 02 2. (2) 2() . 1. 2 5 . 2. 2 2, 3, 4 5 2 ( ) . 3. ( ) . 4. , , . 5. 2 . 6. . 7. . () 2() , , 2() - : , , - : , , 11 (1) - - 2 1 2 5 , , , , - , , - , 3 2, 3 , - , 12 CHAPTER 02 : 3 () . 1. , , ( "" ) 2. 2006 2 3. : 1 2 ( ) , , ( ) . KAIST : 2 () , . : 2 () . : 2 () ( ) . (). 3 () , . 13 (2) ( ) (, , ) , (, , , ) (1) : , (2) : 2 , - : 2 5 . 14 2 17 . . 13 12 - : 3 2 3 , , , - 2 7 - 14 CHAPTER 02 Cardiff School of Art & Design : Research Ethics: A CSAD Handbook of Principles and Proc edures(2014.05) Creative Work : the invention and generation of ideas, images and artefacts including desi gn, as outlined in the Arts & Humanities Research Council s Panel 2 subject cover (Visual Arts and Media: practice, history and theory): Art and design may include: painting; public art; scul pture; performance; installation; time-based art; printmaking; photography; screen productio ns; virtual reality; multimedia; digital and interactive art and design; software design for visual artefacts; animation; illustration; graphic and communication design; art and design in the la ndscape; environmental and interior design; theatre design; exhibition and events design; fa shion; textiles; jewellery and metalwork; ceramics; glass; automotive design; product and fur niture design; art and design management; cultural, theoretical and historical studies (where this is principally contextual to contemporary practice and culture within art and design). The Council will also support research in architecture that concerns building design (but not struc tural or civil or other aspects of engineering). 15 3. (3) 3( ) 2, 3, 4 5 . 1. 5 2. 6 14 3. 1 2 4. 2, 3, 4 . , 2, 3, 4 , . , , , , . ( ) 1 5 6 14 , , ( ) 2 ( ) 3 , 16 CHAPTER 02 (1) ( ) 3 3 , - ' ' '' '' . ( ) 5 . 5 2 1 2 2 4 (2), (3), (4). () ( ) 6, 14 : 3 ( ) ( ) , , . : 3 ( ) , . , . . : 3 () ( ) . ( ) 17 4. (4) 4() , , , . ( ) ( ) : 3 () . : 3 () . : 3 ( ) (). . , . 18 CHAPTER 02 19 03 CHAPTER 1. (5) 2. (6) 3. (9) 1. (5) 5( ) , . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. , 8. , 9. , , ( ) 10. ( ) (2018 ) 9. , , ( ) , 12( ) ( ) 10 (1) ( ) 5( ) 10 6( ) 5 - () ( , ) 22 CHAPTER 03 ( 5), ( 5), ( 5 2) ( 2 4~10), ( 4 2), ( 1 1~4), ( 2~3) , , . : 5 ( ) , , , , . : 34 ( ) , . 23 2. (6) 6( ) . . . . . . , , , , . , , . 24 CHAPTER 03 ( ) 2() 2 , , , ( ) , , , , , , (2018 ) 6 7 , , , 12( ) 6 3, 4, 5 " " 25 (1) ( ) 6 3, 4 ( ) , , . (IRB) . 10 1 ( ) 11 1 1, 5 1) : 2) : 1, 1, 1 3) : 5 , () , () () 4) : ( ) ( ) 5) : ( ) 6) : 7) : (: O , , , O ) 26 CHAPTER 03 : 4( ) . : 5 () . ( ) 6 5 . , , - , : 64 ( ) . 6. : 6() . 2. , 3. : 4( ) 2 7. 27 (2) ( ) 6 5 ( , , , ) ( ) (, ) : 6 () , , . 28 CHAPTER 03 3. (9) 9( ) 17 1 . , , , . 1. 2. 3. , 4. 5. ( "" ) 6. 7. ( ) 17 1, 2. : (2016.11.29 ) 17( ) 15 1 , . < 2013. 3. 23.> . < 2013. 3. 23.> 9 29 04 CHAPTER 1. (11) 2. (12) 3. (13) 1. (11) 11( ) , . . ( ) . 14( ) 2 ( ) 11 1 - 9 3 , : 64 ( ) . 2. : 12 ( ) . , . 32 CHAPTER 04 2. (12) ( ) 12( ) , (1) 12( ) , , . 1. , 2. 3. , 3 . . . . () ( ) 12 () 1) , , , , (privileged information), 2) 33 3) (KAMJE) , (), , 1) - , , , , : 28 ( ) (, , , , ) . . . : 15 () () , 3 () () . 2. , . , (, , , ) 6. 1) (2013). . pp.12-14. 34 CHAPTER 04 (2) 12( ) , , . () 4. , . . . 5. , () ( ) 12 1 , 3( ) () 13 2 ( ) , . ( ) , . 35 : 31() . , . . , . : 16 ( ) . () , . , . () . , , . () 36 CHAPTER 04 (3) , , 12( ) , , . () 6. 7. 1 . ( ) , , 1) ( 12 1 6 ) 2) , ( 12 1 7) ( 12 2) 37 12 1 6 , . . : 27( ) . 2 1 . : 19( ) . 38 CHAPTER 04 ' ' , ( ) 13 1 3 , , , : 4( ) 8. 2 : 4( ) 7. : 32() . 1. 2. 3. : 14( ) , , ( ) . 22() . 1. : , 2. : , , , , 3. : , 4. : , , 5. : , , , 39 (4) ( ) ( ) , ( 12 1 6 ). . , , : 10() . 2. 4. , . , , , : 40 CHAPTER 04 3. (13) 13( ) . 1. 2. 3. , , , 12 1 7 . () 13( ) 12( ) ( ) 12 , , , (honest error) () 13 , , . 41 . : 14( ) . 42 CHAPTER 04 43 05 CHAPTER 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. (14, 15) (14)1-1 14( ) , . . , , , . , . . 3 . . . (1) 1) ( ) 14 2 . - ( ) 2) ( ) : , , , , : , , , , ( ) 46 CHAPTER 05 : , , , ( , , ) : , , , , 3) , . ( ) (, , ) : 10() . , . . 3. (2) 1) , 12 1 6 47 2) 14 7( ) 14 3 3) 11( ) 1, 28 () 1, 30( ) 2 14 2( ), 7( ) , , : 10() ( "" ) , , , . . . , . . 1. 2. 3. 4. , . 48 CHAPTER 05 (15)1-2 15( ) , . . . , 29 3 . , . () , () () 29( ) 3 , , , 49 : 21 ( ) , . : 67 67(, ) , . , . , . 50 CHAPTER 05 2. (16, 27) (16)2-1 16( ) . ( ) . ( ) ( ) . (1) 1) 2) , 1, 3) , 4) . ( : ( ) , ) 5) , , 6) 18 4 , () , () 51 : 3 () . 1. , , ( "" ) 2. 2006 2 3. 52 CHAPTER 05 (27)2-2 27( ) 16 1 . . 1. 2. 3. 2 ( ) 1) , 2) ( 22 ), 3) 2 - 27 3 2 , 16( ) (1) 53 , . (: . ) 54 CHAPTER 05 (19, 20, 24, 25, 28, 29)2-3 (1) 2) 24 24, 6 19 19, 30 19, 10 29, 30 25, 30 25, 60 20 , 24, 29, 30 25, 30 25, 60 28 28, 30 1) : 30 (19) 2) : 6 ( 24). 3) : 30 , 60 4) : 30 2) (2015), , p.96. 55 (2) 3) 1) ( ) 2) 3) 6 , : 66 ( ) . 1. 2. 3. 30 , 10 . 6 . 30 , 60 . 3)(2015), , p.96. 56 CHAPTER 05 3. (21, 22) (21)3-1 21( ) 1 5 . 1 . 1. 30% 2. 50% , 1 ( ) () ( 19 1). 1 5 - 50% , 30% 1 57 : 16 () 5 ( ) : 8 ( ) 10 3 . . : 12 ( ) 3 , 1 . 1 . : 17 ( ) 3 , 3 1 . . (1) 1) , 4) 2) . - 50% , 30% 5) 5 7 9 11 13 15 3 4 5 6 7 8 2 3 3 4 4 5 4) (2015), , p.97. 5) (2015), , p.97. 58 CHAPTER 05 , : 16 ( ) 1 5 . , . 50% , 30% . : 14 ( ) 10 5 , 1 . 2 1 , 3 1 . , . : 4 ( ) 1 5 . . 1 . . 30% . . 50% , 1 . 6) , , . 6) . 59 (22)3-2 22( ) . 1. 777 2. 3. 18 1 , . . () , 22 1 () (, ), , ( ) 22 2 , ( , ) ( ) , (22 1) () , ( 12 1 6) () " " (p.38 ) ( ) 22 3 ( ) 60 CHAPTER 05 : 16 ( ) . (1) 1) 23 3 2) 22 1 3. , 3 3) 4) 22 1, 3 5) 22 2 . 61 (2) () ( 22 2) 1) 22 2 . 22 1 2) . 22 2 62 CHAPTER 05 4. (17, 18, 19, 20) (17)4-1 17( ) . , . , . . . ( ) 1 ( 16 1 ) ( ) ( 349, 350 ) 63 7) 349 , 350 . , ( ). (Preponderance of evidence) 8) , . , , , . (1) 1) ( ) 17 3 , 2) ( ) 17 3 , , 3) ( ) 7) (2015), , p.95. 8) (2014), , p.37. 64 CHAPTER 05 : 65( ) 5 . : 28() . : 20() . : 32() . : 6() , , . 65 (18)4-2 18( ) , . . 16 1 . . ( ) 3 : ( 19) : ( 20) : , ( 24) ( ) ( ) ( ) 7 ( ) , 1) () 18 1 , . , 3 2 , . 2) () 5 , , 5 3 , 3 2 . 66 CHAPTER 05 3) () , , 3 2 ( ) 2 (fast track) . 1) ( ) , ( 18 2) 2) ( ) ( 19 2) ( ) 1 ( 16 1). , 18 3 ( ) 18 4 ( ) . 67 , , ( ) : 11() . , 7 3( ) 6( ) 3 2 3 2 . : 9() 3 2 . : 1( ) . , 3 2 3 2 . . 68 CHAPTER 05 (19)4-3 19() , 30 . . . 23 2 . 10 , . , . () ( 19 1). () 1) ( 19 2). 2) ( 19 4). ( ) 14( ) 2 , , . - 19 3 23( ) 2 - , , , 69 ( ) , 30 ( 25() 1). 25 2 60 ( ) ( ) , . 00 : , . (1) 1) 19 1 1 . - 5 ( 21( ) 1) , 3 2) 3) , . , . - , ( 19 4 ) V. , 3. , 3-1. . 70 CHAPTER 05 (20)4-4 20() , 21 . , . () : , , , : : . . () ( 19 1), () ( 25) ( 28) , , , ( 20 2). 71 23( ) , , , . , . . ( ) 23 2 ( ) 1 , ( 17( ) 1) ( ) 23 3 72 CHAPTER 05 (1) . , . : 18( ) , . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. , . . . . 73 (24, 25)4-5 24() . 6 . , , . () ( 20() 2) ( 25) () , () 6 (1) 6 1) 6 , , 2) 6 , , 3) , 74 CHAPTER 05 25( ) 30 . 1 60 . () , ( 29( ) 1). , , , ( ) , 1 ( ) ( ) ( ) 25() 28() . - ( ) ( ) ( ) 1 2 . 1 75 : 5(, , ) . . . . , . . KAIST : 18( ) 15 , 15 . 30 . 76 CHAPTER 05 (2) 1) , ( 19 4 ) 2) , . : 21() , . . 77 06 CHAPTER 1. 2. 3. (31) 1. (26) 26( ) , . . . () , () . 80 CHAPTER 06 2. (29) 29( ) 3 1 , 30 . () ( ) , ( 29 1). - 30 , 30 . (1) 1) 29 30 , 10 2) ( 3 ), 3) 30 : 27 ( ) ( 263) 3 1 , 30 . 81 (2) 29( ) () 1 . 1. . . . . 2. . . . . . , . . 2 , . 1. 2. 3. 1) 12 1 6 2 2) 22( ) 2 , 82 CHAPTER 06 3) 29 2 , 4) 31 2 , 5) 31 3 . 6) 31 2 3 . , 83 3. (31) 31( ) , , 5 , 29 1 10 . . , , , . ( ) 9) 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) ( ) 10) 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 9) (2015), , p.117. 10) (2015), , p.117. 84 CHAPTER 06 ( ) 1) ( 22( ) 2) 2) ( 31( ) 2) () , , , , , , . 29( ) (2) 85 (1) 1) , 2) 31( ) 1 5 . 5 5 3) 5 . , , , 4) (, , , ) , , , : 27( ) 5 . 5 5 . 86 CHAPTER 06 87 07 CHAPTER 1. ( 1, 2) 1. ( 1, 2) 1() . 2( ) . ( ) 2011 . ( ) , ( ) . ( ) 1) , 2) , 3) ( ) , ( , ), 90 CHAPTER 07 : 2 ( ) (2006.12.19) . , . : 14() ( 263) 3( ) 1 . 10 . : 122( ) 3( ) 1 . 5 . , 2007 . 91 08 CHAPTER 94 CHAPTER 08 (2018) (2013). , (2014), (2015), (2019), 2018 (2019), Machacek, V. & Srholec. M. (2017). Predatory Journals in Scopus. IDEA, March 2017, Center for Economic Research and Graduate Education of the Econom- ics Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences. 95 OO () - . - . : 0000.00.00 : 0000.00.00 : 1 1 () OO( ) , , , . 2() . 1. "" , , . 2. " " , , . 3. "" 2 . 4. "" . 5. "" . 96 CHAPTER 08 3 ( ) , . , , , , , . . 1. 5 2. 6 14 3. 1 2 4. . 2 4 ( ) , , , . , . 1. () , . 2. () . 97 3. () , 3 . . . . . . . () 4. ( ) . . . . . . . , , . , , , , . , . . , , , 5. ( ) , . . 98 CHAPTER 08 . , , . . . , . (letter, communication) (full paper) . . 6. ( ) . . . . 4 1 1 6 7. () . 3 5 ( ) , , . , . 99 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. , 8. , 9. 6 ( ) . , , . , , . 1. . 2. . 3. 3 . 4. 00 . 5. 30 . 6. . 7 ( ) . . 1 . 100 CHAPTER 08 8 ( ) . . 4 9 ( ) . 1. 2. , , 3. 4. 10 ( ) , . , , . . 101 5 11 ( ) , ( University Committee on Research Integrity, '' ) . , . 12 ( ) . . 13 () 1 10 . , (, ) , . . 3 5 . . 14 () , . . 102 CHAPTER 08 15 ( ) 2 , . 16 ( ) 1 , 1 . . 17 () . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. , , 9. 18 () . 3 2 . , 17 2 5 3 2 3 2 . . . 103 19 () . 6 20 ( ) . , . . 1. 2. 3. 4. , 21 ( ) . . 22 ( ) . 1. 2. 3. , , , 104 CHAPTER 08 23 ( ) , . . 24 () . 20 2 . 5 30 , 00 . . 1. 4 2. , . 25 ( ) 10 . . . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 105 26 ( ) . 30 , . 00 . 3 . 27 ( ) 5 . 50% , 30% . . . 28 ( ) . . , . , . 29 ( ) , . 106 CHAPTER 08 , , . , . , , . , . 30 ( ) . , . 1 2 . 1 3 . 31 ( ) . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. , , 6. 7. 107 32 () . . , . 15 . 1 5 . 6 . , . 33 ( ) 30 . 60 . , . . 108 CHAPTER 08 7 34 ( ) , . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. , . . 1. 2. 30 . 30 . 3 . 35 ( ) 5 . 5 5 . , . 109 36( ) , . . 37 () . (1) () 0000 00 00 . (2) () (/) 0000 00 00 . 110 CHAPTER 08 111 , . . CRE CRE : : : 042-869-6355 / : 2020 5 21 / : 02-313-6571~2 (PDF) (http://kucre.or.kr) . Korean University Council of Research Ethics .

2021-06-03